0 20
DO NOT BUY MOBILES PHONES FROM CHINA
Post 1 of 41

(This was written for Australian member,Jonno, in answer to questions in other Topicsbut equally applies to all Western buyers thinking about importing mobile phones.)

.

Hey there Jonno

.

It's Christmas eve here in Aus and I'm about to close office but I'll give you some time hereas I can seeyou are headed for deep trouble - either byCustoms seizing your phones or by our Federal Government's ACMA bankrupting you with massive fines. I well know whatI'm talking aboutas one of my company's activities is importinglarge volumes of mobile phonesfor wholesale to Australian phone shops.

.

CHINESE PHONE FACTORIES

.

The saga begins in China. With300 million mobile phone users, China itself is the world's largestmarket for mobile phones. I can point you to four multi-billion dollar manufacturers plusno less than50 smaller genuine factories (mostly in SZ) all making good quality product for the Chinese domestic market (before considering the hundreds of shonky outfits churning out sub-standard knock offs of Western brand name phones).EACH ONE OF THOSE FIFTY GOOD FACTORIES IS ENTIRELY USELESS FOR YOUR PURPOSE OF IMPORTING PHONES INTO AUSTRALIA (OR INTO ANY OTHER WESTERN COUNTRY)- unless you want to spend $100k for laboratory certification of your chosen phone and then purchase no less than 1,000 phones under every ongoing order.

.

In essence, I can tell you from experience thatany factory which makes acceptable quality phones deals in only 1,000 MOQ and if the phones are not certified by the Western Government in the country of destination you will land in more shite than you can ever imagine (even for small quantity imports).

.

WESTERN LAW

You see, every Western country has its own set of Health, Safety, EMC and Radio standards for mobile phones generally higher than Chinese standards (including for any other device which emits radio waves such as Bluetooth etc).These standards are enshrined in statutory law in every Western country andareenforcedthrough laboratory certification of every phone model (or other radio device) imported for resale in the West.Certificate numbers are issued tothe head phone importer / distributor and this number must be affixed to every phone.

.

Look under the battery in your legal Australianmobile phone. You will see an "A" symbol followed by a number. This is known as an "A-Tick" in the trade.This A-Tick number is issued by our Federal Government'sAustralian Communication and Media Authority (ACMA) to the head importer / distributor.

.

In the event of problems, our ACMA policing authoritycan then identify the importer of any phone by reference to the A-tick number on any phone. The same processapplies to EU,and etc under different sticker systems.

.

CERTIFICATION

To get an A-Tick number (or the equivalent in any other Western country) the imported phone must firstly be certified by an approved laboratory as complying with thestandards in the countryof destination.To avoid cheating only certain labs are "approved" (and you won't find these in ).

.

The full range of lab tests for any one specificmodel of phone costs no less than $100,000.If the phone meets the tests you will get your lab certificate. If the phone fails you lose your money. So, it's a $100k roll of the dice when you lab test Chinese phones.

.

Once you get your lab certificates, the Australian Government will then issue you with your A-Tick number for only that particular model of phone. Your A-Tick must not be used by any other importer / distributor and must not be used on any other model of phone. This process of tracking each phone importer and each phone model makes it impossible for scam suppliers to affix fake A-Ticks (the same in and EU and etc).

.

After the Government issues your A-Tick number, youthen instructyour phone factory to affix your A-Tick number to the phone during the manufacturing process BEFORE they are imported.

.

A couple of sample phones for testing purpose mayslip through ok but don’t try to sell them.

.

POLICING

Broadly, Australian Customs seize phonesnot bearing your A-Tick number. Or,if the phones slip inwithout an A-Tick, our ACMA will track down and prosecute the importer / distributor with a fury you don't want to know about (much the same applies in all Western countries).

.

And, that's just the start of the red tape. The importer / distributor must maintain certainrecords in a separate file as set out in the regulations and this file isfield audited by ACMA from time to time. Stuff it up and they'll eat you alive. Again, every Western country has its own equivalent of our ACMA policing authority monitoring phones for sale in the public domain.

.

The A-tick files in my office are maintained with a religious fervour under lock and key as they must be instantly available for any surprise ACMA audit.

In USA, the authoritieswill literally throw you in prison for selling phones whichdo not comply with USA's FCC regulations.

.

STANDARDS

I mentioned Health, Safety, EMC and Radio standards. The severity of these standards variesfrom country to country far too complex to go into here, butin short ...

.

Firstly,the Health standards mainly concern the level of emission of radio waves from phone aerials. Excessive emission causes hot spots in human flesh. In the case of phones, these hot spots occur particularly in the human brain because the phone is held close tothe ear. Consequently, every Western Government has laws mandating the maximum acceptable emission because unacceptably high emissions can cause serious injury to human brain tissue via hot spots ( has the world's toughest emissionstandard by far).

.

Lab tests to measure the strength of these radio wavesare called SAR tests. Sell phones in any Western country not lab certified for SAR and you are a dead man because Western governments take this health risk of hot spots in the human brain very seriously (as indeed they should).

.

I have seen Chinese phones first hand which cause the flesh in your ear to actually get hot after 10 minutes on the phone. Nobody cares about a hot ear but the radio waves causing that heat also penetrateyour brain tissue so I shudder to think of the hot spots in one's brain tissueby excessive emissionsfrom some uncertified phones.

.

You are placing people's health on the line and maybe even your own health, or thehealth of your own family members, when you import and distribute uncertified mobile phones.

.

Secondly, part of thelab tests concern the integrity of the engineering design of thephone. An improperly made phone can bring down an entire radionetwork landing you in a multi-million damages claim for uncertified phones disrupting a carrier's network.

.

In summary, Western Governmentstandards are not just useless Government red tape. They protect usfrom excessiveradio wave emissions harming our brain tissue and they protect us from badly designed phones knockingourmobile phone networks off the air.

.

To import and sell uncertified phones in any western country is put your entire assets on the line for massive Government fines and/or damages claims from network carriers or injured consumers.

.

CAUSE OF THE PROBLEM

.

Putting aside the shonky factories, makes 70% of all the world's legal mobile phones falling into mostly two classes. First, the closed shop dealsbetween the major Western brand names and major first tier Chinese phone factories (you can't get a look-in here so forget these). Second, the dozens of second tier genuine factories (as well as the first tier) who manufacture for the massive domestic Chinese market.

.

By the sheer size of their own market, these good second tier factories areusually not interested in the Western market (and/ortheir exports are limited to non-developed countries which do not have rigid Western standards). Consequently, these factoriesdo not get lab certifications for their phones forWestern markets as it's all too hard and costly.

.

The problem for small Western buyers is those one thousand or so smart-*** Chinese based in HK and SZ who buy China-suited phones from the second tier factories and then promote thesetolittle Western buyers who know nothing of the certification laws in their respective countries.

.

In other words, these smart-*** middleman sellers trade on the ignorance of little Western buyers who are unaware oftheirown country's certification laws. The promotion is done mainly throughEBay and Alibaba and the dozens of other smaller B2B sites.

.

Additionally, there is a recenttrend among a few of thesecond tier factories to hire exportsales people to target Western buyers in completeignorance of Western certification laws. Here, you finish with well meaning butignorant Chinese sales people doing deals witheven more ignorantlittle Western buyers culminating in disaster upon disaster at the end of the day.

.

(cond below)

23 Dec 2007 18:56
Post 2 of 41

Some of Alibaba's scam phone sellers are listed on Wilhelm's good topic here:

http://resources.alibaba.com/topic/204677/Alphabetic_List_Fujian_Region_incl_Putian_fake_Nokia_selling_companies_.htm?va=0

Wilhelm's list names about 100 out of some 1,000 Alibaba scam phone dealers.

Congratulations Alibaba for conducting the world's largest B2B platform for scam phone sellers.  [em1]

27 Mar 2008 15:36
Post 3 of 41
Replying to [Aussie]:

A bit off topic here Aussie ,but I thought a bit of thanks to you was in order (NOT) .After reading your articles ,ref CE / A Tick etc certifications I decided to read up about the subject. So started delving around on the Euro Gov sites.

After many many hours of reading the regulations and directives , I can now say you contributed to an almost brain dead state in me .Who writes that stuff ? These guys dont write in any understandable form of English that I know of.

If your Aussie legislators are as bad as the Euro ones ,then you have my sympathies .

My little notion of trying something with CE requirements will now go to specialist folks ,who can then return to me with definitive info.

Joking aside ,any one wishing to take on CE certification ,you should get yourself in to those EU Gov sites .A lot to be learned ,before expensive mistakes being the potential outcome for you .

28 Mar 2008 10:07
Post 4 of 41

[em2][em2]

Hi, how's it going these days mate.
 
Yep, those EU directives are sure a mouthful even for me and I've had legal training. A case of too many cooks spoiling the broth I guess ... all those different EU cooks writing a common menu to please all member countries resulting in directives that nobody understands. 
 
The good news (once you work it out) is that the EU is much less regulated than our over-regulated Australian and USA mobile phone markets.
 
The other good news is that several more Chinese phone factories I'm talking with have now agreed to pay for proper mobile phone certification for the West. Maybe by the end of 2008, we can change this topic to "Buy Mobile Phones from China". The key is of course that buyer's co-op we're talking about for all the little guys to share in the big factory MOQs of 1,000 to 5,000 phones at the right price.
 
Nothing I'd love more than to bust open the closed phone shop in the West which Nokia and the boys presently own. [em3]
28 Mar 2008 19:35
Post 5 of 41
Quoting from [eutrade]:


Replying to [Aussie]:


Hi Aussie.


Another good & enlightening post from you regarding the mobile phone market and its workings.


I know you concentrated on the Australian regulations etc ,for purposes of the post .But heres the UK take on the potential for disaster ,should buyers put $ savings before end user safety etc . HM customs & excise together with the judicial system here , > they will slaughter your business.And in more ways than money .Pure and simle.


Goods confiscated and destroyed is the least of the worries.The follow through is the real trouble .Court appearance ,possible enormous fines ,possibly even loss of freedom . That IS the reality here .


EU countries" legal systems are essentially all grouped under the one umbrella ,so no real escape when irregularities are highlighted .



Man, it is this easy.  You the buyer looking for phones from China are being creedy.  You want to make a ton of cash and think because you saw under the battery on your personal cell it says Made in China.  Well you then say to yourself, I heard that stuff is cheap in China, like I can trade dirt for laptops and stuff.  Guess what?  You will not save any money, you will get scammed, lose you money, get refurb phones you cannot sell on ebay (we know that is why you are here), and possible legal fines, jail time, and a lawsuit from a customer with half a brain.  Find an authorized distributor in your country, need help ask me.  Nuff said.
16 Apr 2008 20:16
Post 6 of 41
artrageous
offline
No Company Website yet
Overall Ranking MVP:52 Rank:133,273
Quoting from [Aim Direct USA]:

Quoting from [eutrade]:



Replying to [Aussie]:



Hi Aussie.



Another good & enlightening post from you regarding the mobile phone market and its workings.



I know you concentrated on the Australian regulations etc ,for purposes of the post .But heres the UK take on the potential for disaster ,should buyers put $ savings before end user safety etc . HM customs & excise together with the judicial system here , > they will slaughter your business.And in more ways than money .Pure and simle.



Goods confiscated and destroyed is the least of the worries.The follow through is the real trouble .Court appearance ,possible enormous fines ,possibly even loss of freedom . That IS the reality here .



EU countries" legal systems are essentially all grouped under the one umbrella ,so no real escape when irregularities are highlighted .




Man, it is this easy.  You the buyer looking for phones from China are being creedy.  You want to make a ton of cash and think because you saw under the battery on your personal cell it says Made in China.  Well you then say to yourself, I heard that stuff is cheap in China, like I can trade dirt for laptops and stuff.  Guess what?  You will not save any money, you will get scammed, lose you money, get refurb phones you cannot sell on ebay (we know that is why you are here), and possible legal fines, jail time, and a lawsuit from a customer with half a brain.  Find an authorized distributor in your country, need help ask me.  Nuff said.



Hello,

Where can I find a legitamate dealer in the US for brand name cell phones?

18 Aug 2008 13:44
Post 7 of 41
19 Aug 2008 00:05
Post 8 of 41
accounts
offline
No Company Website yet
Overall Ranking MVP:52 Rank:134,956
Hi Aussie


I really enjoyed your contributions on this site. I have been searching for phones and computer products but have found almost every listing on alibaba is in some way useless to an importer in Australia - fakes, money scams or illegal/unsafe to sell in Australia.

 After trawling through this site any many others for weeks now, I have found no contact that I can trust. Perhaps you can help in some way? feel free to get in touch and scrub my email bookofpleasures.gmail don't worry I'm not so gullible to be scammed (hey I work in advertising!)

I am also producing a magazine next year for business people, would love to get in touch regarding your business advice as we have seen in here.

cheers

Ben

Canberra
05 Oct 2008 20:01
Post 9 of 41
fayetteam
offline
No Company Website yet
Overall Ranking MVP:54 Rank:108,149
I wish I could have found this article earlier. I have purchased 4 Phones from King Kong Tech and  thought everything was ok. I have resold one and am thinking I should get it back after reading this. They are dancing around the question about

producing the  FCC certificate saying they sell to USA all the time and implying I do not know what I am doing, their is an FCC # on the phone but I guess it is not any good. Should I try and get the one back I already sold and destroy the others? Help

I need to do the right thing.

 

  Quoting from [Aussie]

WHAT TO LOOK FOR

.Before you even ask the price, you must ask if the phone is certified.

  • For Australia, you ask for A-Tick certification. 
  • For EU, its CE certification
  • For USA, it's FCC certification

Punch a buyer search for mobile phones into Alibaba at top of this page. Among the tens of thousands of published offers, you will not see even one A-Tick or FCC certification. You will see a couple claiming CE certification. However, when you delve into the latter, you find the CE certificate is not held by the factory or trader but is held by the European importer meaning the CE is useless to you.

.

Then there are the fake brand name phones where every single one of the thousands of published leads on Alibaba for brand name phones is a fake phone. A knock-off phone is one matter but the fact that these phones are not lab tested for certification in Western countries is a far more serious matter. 

.

(cond below)


30 Dec 2008 06:09
Post 10 of 41
heatherzx
offline
No Company Website yet
Overall Ranking MVP:52 Rank:137,366
HI Aussie , that was interesting ... I'm looking at importing/ having made up some torches/ lights / and you enlightened me as to what to look for and what to avoid. Yes it seems like a strange world out there in China Alibabaland with such a vast number of factories and sales reps....

I am thinking battery not rechargable unless its solar recharge and not connected to the mains ...that should be more affordable for me as a start up. Its still hard to trawl through the numbers of manufacturers.

thank you for your time ... hope all is going well .

Heather Carey , Wollongong area heatherzxatyahoodotcomdotau
28 Jan 2009 00:28
Post 11 of 41
represnetative of china export
For mobile business, the author of the said article is a little radical and not so real. The fact is only very few chinese export sales do some tricky things.In most cases, chinese export sales will tell truth to their customers ifmobile isoringal or copied, with certificate or not, etc. They will ask foreign customer to make a decision. Without foreign customer approval, how they can get payment and move forward? some overseabuyer seek high profit and they still need the goods unsatisfied even they know the truth.regarding mobiel business,there are two ways to do. One is for brand business, the purchaser will be big fish and they buy big qty with their own design, logo and packing, etc. But as you know, since mobile factoryies open to do business, they can't stop to wait order coming. In case the factory don't have enough order to make, they will make some popularmodels as stock. Then you will have antoher mode ofmobile business, stock mobile business.of course, some copied mobile also come to market because there is somebodylooking for!!!!. So the most important for business is please ask your chinese export sales tell you truth andnext how you make a decision. In mobile market,a funny things isthat: when our chinese sales promotetheir factory designed models, but 80% oversea customershow no interests and alwaysasking back: do you have nokia, motorola,etc?why,because they sell well in regular mobile market. It is hard for a factory to make a new model and survive. Esp for africa, south africa countries, they only need copy nokia, etc. What should wedo? 
 
it is common sense that for mobile business, you need invest big money to buy qualified goods, develop your sales channel and after-sales services. It is a big project. Why still there are so many small western buyer they want to do mobile business and just use several hundred dollars? what the most strange is why some of them  aways asking prices for  those brand mobile, like nokia n95? and later tell you that they are taken in!!!they are so smart and you can't tell me they don't know this mobile business nature before taking action!!!!!!!!!
 
The author only see the surface and did not touch real substance inside. He can't blame chinese export sales as smart-XXX!!!. what i can say is The fly does not bite the seamless egg! He is one of them and get hurt then curse back like that!!!!
24 Feb 2009 22:51
Email this page Bookmark this page